ERZURUM Metropolitan Municipality

TOTAL SCORE

TIER 10
0
TIER 9
15
TIER 8
25
TIER 7
35
TIER 6
45
TIER 5
55
TIER 4
65
TIER 3
75
TIER 2
85
TIER 1
95
100

Based on its total score for good governance, the municipality is in Tier 7 (35–44 points).

Good Governance Principles

TIER 9
TIER 7
TIER 9
TIER 6
TIER 7
TIER 4
TIER 7

Institutional Processes

TIER 6
TIER 10
TIER 7
TIER 6

Continuous Learning

TIER 5
TIER 7
TIER 9

Assessment of Good Governance Principles

Tier 4 (65–74 points) for Effectiveness & Efficiency. The municipality performs this principle more successfully than the other principles.Effectiveness & Efficiency means producing the best possible and intended outcome without wasting resources. The municipality needs to improve the practices of this principle.

Tier 6 (45–54 points) for Fairness & Inclusiveness. Fairness & Inclusiveness require municipalities to take the needs of different social groups into consideration, and to plan its services, activities, and its investments accordingly. This principle points out important areas of improvement for the municipality.

Tier 7 (35–44 points) for Responsibility & Responsiveness, Transparency and Representation & Participation. Responsibility & Responsiveness require municipalities consider the needs, expectations and rights of both today’s citizens and the future generations while planning. Transparency is important for building trust in municipalities and enables monitoring and assessment for continuous development. Active participation of stakeholders, especially in the planning of service provision and investments, is important for meeting expectations and citizen satisfaction. These principles refer to crucial areas of development for the municipality.

Tier 9 (15–24 points) for Consistency and Accountability. Consistency requires harmony between the activities and plans of municipalities and those of stakeholders. Accountability is important to gain and maintain the trust of stakeholders for the municipalities. These principles are the foremost areas of development for the municipality.

We see that the municipality still needs to improve its approach to good governance and practices of good governance in its institutional functioning.

Good Practice

The municipality has ISO 10002, ISO14001, ISO9001, and OHSAS18001 quality certificates.

Related Governance Principles

Effectiveness & Efficiency

Related ELoGE Principles

Principle 3: Efficiency and Effectiveness

Related SDGs and Targets

SDG 16

Target 16.6. Develop effective, accountable, and transparent institutions at all levels.

Related OECD Wellbeing Indicator

Civic Engagement

Environment

Importance of the Practice

Improving the quality of municipal processes improves efficiency and the effectiveness of municipal services. Quality systems enable institutions to form effective processes. The quality certification shows that the municipality has performed its services based on operational health and safety standards and in an environmentally and citizen friendly manner.

Source: Erzurum Metropolitan Municipality 2021 Annual Report, page 172